Soach Global Is Selling A Fifth Of Its NSE Stake For Up To ₹295 Crore, Five Times What It Paid For All Of It

In this storySSoach GlobalNational Stock Exchange of India

Soach Global, a Mauritius-based fund, is selling 20 per cent of its stake in the National Stock Exchange of India through the exchange's IPO, for proceeds of about ₹280 crore to ₹295 crore. That is nearly five times what it paid for its entire holding a decade ago.

The fund acquired 1.5 lakh NSE shares from Industrial Finance Corporation of India, the state-owned lender, in January 2016, at ₹3,950 a share, for a total of ₹59.25 crore. Over the following decade, corporate actions raised the holding to 82.5 lakh shares with no further investment, bringing its adjusted cost to ₹71.8 a share.

It is selling 16.5 lakh shares through the offer for sale at the IPO price band of ₹1,700 to ₹1,785. It will keep the remaining 66 lakh shares, 80 per cent of the position, valued at about ₹1,120 crore to ₹1,180 crore at the band, as a long-term investment. The fund puts the return on its full position at roughly 25 times.

The seller is Soach Global Strategic Holdings, a wholly owned Mauritius subsidiary of Soach Global Opportunities Fund. Its parent, Hong Kong-based Soach Global Corporation, operates in fund management and advisory.

Founder and director Anubhav Dayal said the fund was selling part of its stake because it wanted to see a large number of retail investors hold a stake in NSE, directly or through mutual funds, and benefit from its growth as the fund had.

NSE's IPO closed on 21 September subscribed about 5.7 times. Qualified institutional buyers bid 12.68 times their allocation. The retail portion finished at around 1.4 times. Allotment is expected today, with listing on BSE on 24 September.

The more telling detail is who sold these shares in the first place.

Soach bought its stake in January 2016 from Industrial Finance Corporation of India, a state-owned lender. It paid ₹59.25 crore. At the top of the IPO price band, those same shares, now 82.5 lakh after a decade of corporate actions, are worth about ₹1,470 crore. The gain between those two numbers went to a Mauritius fund rather than to the public institution that held the stake before.

That is not a scandal. IFCI sold at a price the market set at the time, and NSE in 2016 was an unlisted exchange with uncertain prospects and limited buyers for minority stakes. Nobody was obliged to foresee what it would become.

But it illustrates a pattern that recurs whenever a long-held unlisted asset finally lists. The largest share of the value creation usually accrues to whoever held it in the years just before a liquidity event, not to the original owners and not to the public buyers who arrive at listing.

The arithmetic of Soach's position is striking on its own. A twenty-five-fold gain over roughly ten and a half years works out to an annual return of around 35 per cent, compounding quietly in an unlisted stake. It is the kind of return venture capital promises and rarely delivers, earned instead by holding a near-monopoly exchange.

The quote and the order book do not quite line up.

Dayal said the fund was selling because it wanted large numbers of retail investors to own a piece of NSE. The IPO's subscription data suggests that is not how the shares will be distributed. Institutions bid 12.68 times their allocation. Retail investors finished at roughly 1.4 times, and were below full subscription at the end of the second day. The grey market premium fell by two-thirds while the book was open.

In practice, most of what Soach is selling will go to the buyers who wanted it most, and those were mutual funds, insurers and foreign institutions. Retail ownership will arrive, as Dayal also noted, mostly indirectly, through mutual fund holdings.

That is not a criticism of the fund. Selling a fifth of a position that has compounded twenty-five times, while keeping the rest, is conservative portfolio management by almost any standard.

The more interesting point is structural. An IPO that is entirely an offer for sale is a transfer between two groups of owners rather than a capital raise. The early owners, many of them financial institutions and funds that bought in years ago, convert part of their gains to cash. The new owners buy a mature, debt-free, very profitable business at a price that already reflects most of what made the early owners rich.

The return from here depends on growth that has not happened yet. The return Soach is realising depends on growth that already has, and at a 43 times earnings multiple, the new buyers are paying for a good deal of the future in advance.

For daily, sharp analysis of the biggest moves in the Indian business and startup ecosystem, follow StartupFox.